Institute for Studies In American Music
Conservatory of Music, Brooklyn College of the City University of New York
NEWSLETTER


Volume XXXVII

 


No. 2    Spring 2008

Inside This Issue:

Inside         This Issue

 

I.S.A.M. Beginnings  by H.W.H.

 

I.S.A.M. Matters [1992] by H.W.H.

 

Mail from Wiley by Richard Crawford

 

Everbest: Remembering H. Wiley Hitchcock by Susan Feder

 

H.W.H., Cowell, and New Music by David Nicholls

 

H.W.H. Reflections by Ellie Hisama and Nancy Hager

 

Sitting for a Virgil Thomson Portrait

by H.W.H.

 

 

 

In Spring 1996, while serving as Guest Editor of this Newsletter, I managed to convince Wiley to write of this remarkable experience with a longtime friend. It turned out to be the last article he wrote for this publication. In addition, as Wiley points out below, Two Birds was Thomson’s last completed work (J.T.).

 

 

 

Excerpt from the manuscript for Wiley Hitchcock: Two Birds

Reproduced with permission of the Virgil Thomson Foundation, Ltd.

 

 

 

I saw Virgil Thomson often during his last years, and regularly every summer, when I was in Florence and he came to nearby Montecatini Terme for a few weeks, to take the baths, drink the water, and lose some weight.  (He claimed their salutary effect held him through the “silly season”—Christmas and New Year’s.)  We had lunches or dinners together; I remember two memorable ones, one at his very grand and tranquil hotel—in fact called the Hotel Grand e la Pace—when he introduced me to Betty Freeman, the other when my wife and I took him to Da Delfina in the hill town of Artimino, overlooking a great sixteenth-century Medici villa, and he brought along David and Karen Waltuck, just beginning their rise to fame as chef and hostess of the restaurant Chanterelle in SoHo.  And often, when Virgil’s stay at Montecatini ended, I drove him to the airport at Pisa, to catch a plane for London or wherever he was headed next.

During one of those drives, in the summer of 1986, Virgil murmured, “I’d like to do your portrait.”  Nothing could have surprised or pleased me more.  To join such earlier sitters as Picasso, Gertrude Stein, Paul Bowles, Dorothy Thompson, Lou Harrison, Dennis Russell Davies!

Those were the last frantic days of AmeriGrove’s preparation.  I happened to tell Susan Feder, linchpin of the dictionary’s editorial overseers, about Virgil’s offer.  “Wonderful!” she said.  “Let’s get him to do it right away and have it premiered at the AmeriGrove launch party in November.”  Some Macmillan executive urged the idea on Virgil, who—a famously practical man—struck a deal: OK, a portrait of Hitchcock in return for a free set of the four-volume dictionary and a featured appearance at its launch party.

Back in New York that fall, he called me, and we made a date to meet in his apartment in the Chelsea Hotel on a Saturday afternoon.  I arrived on the dot at 2:00 and rang . . . and rang
. . . and rang.  Finally the door opened.  There was Virgil, in a bathrobe, looking exceedingly sleepy.  “Oh, damn,” he said. “My secretary is off today, and I didn’t notice our date in my book, and I took a nap, and I can’t possibly work just now.  But come in and we’ll have a chat.”  We did—but no portrait.

On a spring day about a year and a half later, Virgil called again about a portrait date, to my surprise (I thought he’d forgotten all about the matter), and we made another appointment.  No bathrobe this time, but a similar invitation to sit down in the living room and chat.  We must have chatted for a good half hour—I was beginning to think he had forgotten why I was there—when suddenly he said, “Well, let’s get to work.  Come on.”  He led me to the dining room.  There on his long, plain dining table was a sheaf of blank music paper, a jar full of sharp pencils, an eraser or two.  He beckoned me to a chair and sat down opposite me, inquiring if I had anything to read.  Yes, I did: bound galleys of Tim and Vanessa Page’s book of selected letters of Virgil Thomson.  And he went to work, with total immersion in the task, never looking up at me or at anything else except the music paper, occasionally erasing and rewriting, totally silent.

About forty-five minutes later he paused and asked, “Are you getting tired?” No, I wasn’t.  Back to work he went.  After about another hour, he gave a little cry of pleasure.  “Look at this!  The end of the page . . . and the end of the piece!  Here, you can look at it—but you can’t ask me any questions about it.  And excuse me, I have to pee.”

What I looked at was a one-page, untitled piece of piano music, basically in two-voice contrapuntal texture but with some octaves, a key signature of G major, no tempo indication but the warnings “senza espressione” and “senza pedale.”  My portrait!

A few days later a package came, addressed, as was Virgil’s practice, to “H. Wiley Hitchcock, Esquire.” It bore the manuscript—now titled—and a note dated 
1 June 1988:  “Dear Wiley,  This is the original made on May 28.  It has been tampered with a little, such as making the notes larger than mere dots and the adding of lots of slurs and other dots.  It has also been sprayed with fixative so that it will not smear.  I hope you like it.  I enjoyed doing it.  Happy times in Europe.  Yours, Virgil.”

I responded with my own note. “Dear Virgil:  I’m pleased and proud to have been a subject for a portrait.  The MS arrived yesterday.  I can’t play it yet: it looks simple but isn’t, rhythmically.  It also looks 100% G-major diatonic—not one accidental on the whole page—but it’s surprisingly acrid. I assume you didn’t necessarily intend me to identify with ‘Wiley’ but I do, and there’s nothing you can do about it. Sincerely, Wiley.”

Virgil didn’t rise to the bait—so cunningly couched, I thought, not as a question but a provocative comment.  Nor did I ever learn what sparked the subtitle “Two Birds.”  Only later did I discover the piece printed as a contribution to a festschrift for me, published as A Celebration of American Music (Ann Arbor:  University of Michigan Press, 1990) two years later.  By then Virgil was gone.  My portrait had been his last completed composition.

—H.W.H.

 

 

 

 

 


ISAM home   Who we are      Contact us       ISAM Conferences and Lectures
 
Monographs   ISAM Web Documents     Newsletters    Links
 
 

Copyright © 2005 Institute for Studies in American Music, Conservatory of Music, Brooklyn College. All Rights Reserved.
Site designed by J. Graeme Fullerton & maintained by Carl Clements, Managing Editor