The MFA degree requires two years and 60 credits for completion. The program combines course work in theater history, dramatic theory, criticism, literature, and technique with intensive practical training through on-campus productions as well as through professional internships and residencies at some of the most prestigious theater organizations in New York City. These include the Manhattan Theatre Club, New York Shakespeare Festival, Playwrights Horizons, Lincoln Center, the New York City Opera, the Brooklyn Academy of Music, Jujamcyn Theaters, Columbia Artists Theatricals, and the Roundabout Theatre Company. A student's first year of study concludes in a pre-thesis evaluation based on a performance project and/or on a faculty review of academic progress. The second year culminates in a thesis production, performance, or project, and a related thesis paper.

The MA in history and criticism is designed for scholars, teachers, and writers. Some of those who graduate enroll in a Ph.D. program, many at The Graduate Center of the City University of New York, which accepts all credits earned at Brooklyn College. Thirty credits are required for completion. With the proper prerequisites and departmental permission, students may also select courses in their specialized disciplines from any of the schools in The CUNY system as well as the CUNY Graduate Center.

Students must demonstrate fluent English in their speech and writing. Non-native speakers of English who are applying for the concentrations in acting, directing, dramaturgy, history and criticism, and performing arts management must achieve at least a 600 on the TOEFL language exam.

Students are required to fulfill the responsibilities of a crew Head on at least one departmental production during their first year as part of their practical theater training and discipline. This requirement will contribute to the credits for Acting I and II.